MASTERS ON AUDIO AND VIDEOFeatures Archives

July 15, 2002

 

Batteries Not Included

It used to baffle me at electronics trade shows that several big international companies spent a lot of effort putting together press kits devoted to their battery lines. I couldn't imagine that any of the journalists attending the show cared much about batteries, and I certainly had never seen an article about them.

But batteries are definitely a big deal. Just consider how many things you use every day that employ batteries, even some you may not be aware of. The computer I am writing this on has a hidden battery, for instance, whose only function is to keep the internal clock going when the power goes off. Other devices have tiny batteries to power memory chips that hold the settings you have programmed in.

And then there are the obvious battery-driven things, from cell phones to portable CD players to TV remote controls. If you do a quick audit of the things you own, you'll be astounded at how many batteries you use in a day. But chances are you know very little about them.

Almost all the electricity we use is produced one of two ways. The first is electromagnetically generated by the power utilities and conducted to our houses by wires from massive generating plants. It doesn't matter whether coal or natural gas or nuclear power is the originating energy; each one simply creates motion so a bank of magnets can induce a current in a coil of wire. It's like an electric motor in reverse. Mostly such power is alternating current, in which the polarity -- the direction the power moves through the wires -- switches back and forth some sixty times a second (in North America, at least; some other parts of the world use fifty).

The other derives electrical energy from a chemical reaction. Strictly speaking, the basic power-generating unit in this case is called a "cell"; if a number of cells are strung together they become a battery. In practice, however, most people use the word battery whether single or multiple cells are used.

A battery consists of two electrodes made of dissimilar materials, separated by a medium called an electrolyte. The electrodes react differently to the electrolyte, one (called the anode) becoming negatively charged, the other (the cathode) acquiring a positive change. If you were to connect the two directly, using a piece of wire, these charges would cancel each other out very quickly, as the extra electrons of the anode would race through the wire to make up a deficiency of electrons in the cathode.

Instead of such a "short circuit," the movement of the electrons can be made to do work, by illuminating a light bulb, say, or driving an electric motor or electronic circuit. This electricity is "direct current," in which the electrons always flow in the same direction (anode to cathode).

The first cell was developed about 1800 by Alessandro Volta, who separated disks of silver and zinc by layers of cloth or paper soaked in an electrolyte such as brine. The unit of electrical potential, the volt, is named after him.

France’s Gaston Planté invented the forerunner of the modern car battery -- the lead-acid cell -- in 1859. His countryman, Georges Leclanché, came up with the dry cell about thirty years later. The dry cell was the ancestor of the familiar flashlight battery, although the name is a bit of a misnomer. While the lead-acid cell used (and still uses) a liquid electrolyte that can spill, the dry cell used a paste or jelly, which is much more physically stable.

The dry cell and its kin are what are known as "primary" batteries. There is a finite amount to the reaction of the electrodes and the electrolyte, after which electricity ceases to be produced, and the battery must be discarded.

In a perfect battery, the reaction would only take place when the electrons were being drawn off to do work; when the circuit is broken, the reaction should stop. In reality, there are impurities in the materials used to make batteries that let the reaction continue in a reduced amount even when the battery is not in use, which means that cells have a shelf life, and will ultimately die even if not connected to anything.

The lead-acid cell is a "secondary" battery, in which the chemical reaction that produces electricity can be reversed by applying a current from an external source to the electrodes in the reverse direction. Such devices were once known as "accumulators" or storage batteries; now they're generally called "rechargeable" batteries.

In theory, the number of times you could restore full power to a secondary battery should be limitless, but again, no device is perfect, and eventually the battery will no longer take a charge, as any car owner knows.

The most common batteries are primary zinc-manganese-dioxide cells -- "flashlight batteries." One of the electrodes, the anode, is the zinc-alloy outer shell of the battery; the cathode is manganese dioxide formed around a carbon rod in the battery's center. In between is an electrolyte that's mostly ammonium chloride, with some zinc chloride added.

An improvement on this design was patented in 1899, in which zinc chloride alone is used in the electrolyte and much purer materials can be used for the electrodes, extending the life of the battery. Even longer service can be obtained with a battery which is basically similar to the zinc-manganese sort, but which uses an alkaline electrolyte.

All of these designs produce a similar voltage -- roughly 1.5V -- which means they are interchangeable. Greater operating voltages can be obtained by stringing batteries in series, most flashlights using two, for instance, many other devices using four or more. The size of the battery affects its life, not how much voltage it produces.

Several other systems - mercuric-oxide-zinc and silver-oxide-zinc -- typically come in the form of button batteries, useful for watches, hearing aids, and cameras.

The most recent family of batteries use an anode made of lithium, which exhibits a high degree of chemical activity. In some applications, lithium batteries can produce higher voltages than conventional batteries. Other types are able to operate at extremely low temperatures.

The most common secondary batteries have traditionally been the lead-oxide variety. The car version of this is perhaps the best known, characterized by its ability to give hundreds of brief discharges over a number of years. The technology is also used in things like lift trucks, where they may weigh several tons, the weight helping to stabilize the vehicle. They are also used for emergency power systems because of their long shelf life.

More recent are the rechargeable batteries used in a variety of consumer items, such as camcorders. The most familiar is the Nickel-cadmium (NiCad), which turns up almost everywhere. The main virtue of the NiCad battery is its ability to be recharged numerous times. It suffers from a much shorter operating cycle per charge than most primary batteries, however, and is best recharged only when it has been completely flattened. Otherwise, it will only take a partial charge, and the lower-percentage charge is cumulative, so that after a number of charges the battery will only hold a small amount of power. Some chargers have a "refresh" mode that intentionally discharges the battery completely before recharging it, but most do not.

A more recent development is the nickel-metal-hydride (NiMH) battery, which does not exhibit the same sort of charging "memory" as the NiCad.

Both types of battery take about 12 to 14 hours to charge with the typical charger. Manufacturers could make the process faster or slower, but the "overnight" charge is a good compromise because it involves levels of current that won't damage the battery if it's connected after a full charge is reached. Reducing the power for the same reason runs the risk that a full charge will never be achieved.

For some, it's tempting to consider replacing all one's primary batteries with rechargeables, but in reality, both types have their place. In devices that are used for relatively short periods, but frequently, and require high power levels, secondary batteries are probably appropriate, and in fact most such units come with their own charging systems. For things that need little power or are only used occasionally, old-style throwaway batteries are undoubtedly the more economic choice.

...Ian G. Masters
ian@mastersonaudio.com


MASTERS ON AUDIO AND VIDEOAll Contents Copyright © 2002
Schneider Publishing Inc., All Rights Reserved.
Any reproduction of content on
this site without permission is strictly forbidden.