MASTERS ON AUDIO AND VIDEOTips & Techniques Archives

July 15, 2004

 

When Oldies Were Hard to Find

Little sisters can be a big pain, as any brother will attest. I managed fairly successfully to ignore mine throughout most of my childhood, except on one disastrous occasion when one of them hit me where I was most vulnerable: in the record collection.

One summer, as the departure date for summer camp approached, my sister made a deal with a buddy: the friend would take her family's portable record player to camp, and my sister would take some records. Mine.

Normally, touching my records would be a killing offence, but I was away at the time and knew nothing about it. What I also didn't know was that the friend's record player was an old wind-up 78 acoustic job with a tonearm whose tracking weight could probably be measured in pounds. It apparently never occurred to them that you couldn't just throw any record on any old record player and expect it to work.

The steel needle on this machine did a thorough job of carving up the soft vinyl of my 45s. Amazingly enough, my dear sister and her pal did not say "Oops! This doesn't work" after wrecking the first disc. Instead they ruined all of the half-dozen records they'd purloined. By the time I got them back, they were gray and unplayable.

Nowadays, after wreaking some horrible revenge on her, I'd just go out and buy new copies of those songs (preferably at her expense), but things didn't work that way in the ‘50s and ‘60s. They were irreplaceable, at least for the time being.

It seems remarkable, in these days when kids are listening to and buying the records their parents (even grandparents) grew up with, that music back then was as ephemeral as, say, magazines are today. There were no oldies sections in record stores, no oldies labels, and only the mildest attempt by radio stations to exercise their back collections.

The local rock station might play a "Solid Gold" oldie occasionally (rarely more than five years old), and at least one radio station of my acquaintance did have a nightly oldies program that ran for an hour in the middle of the night. My friend Joe and I would listen to this and keep score, noting how many of the tracks that they played we had in our own combined collections. The average was about two thirds.

That we could do it at all was the result of our feeling that if we liked a record when it appeared, we'd probably continue to like it. So the first time something good showed up on the radio, we'd trot down to one of the record shops and buy it. There was some urgency to that because, unless it was a major hit, the stores might only have a couple of copies, and were unlikely to restock it. Even with bestsellers, when the radio stopped playing them, they disappeared from the stores.

The occasional reissue did appear. Columbia had a Hall of Fame series that made a very small selection of catalog material available. And it was sometimes possible to find older hits reissued on one of an artist's LPs, although that was usually too expensive a way for us to buy music in those days.

One place we did visit from time to time, and did manage to pick up a few bargains, was a store that had several bins full of second-hand 45s rescued from jukeboxes, which sold for a nickel apiece. Occasionally one of these would be fairly clean, especially if it wasn't too popular a song, but mostly they resembled those discs my sister brought back from camp.

The frustrating thing was that I knew there were gaps in my collection: records that I hadn't bought when they were new, and now had no way to obtain.

It was with amazement and delight, therefore, that I discovered on a visit to New York a store that had a whole section devoted to oldies, mostly in pristine reissues. I scooped up an armful of these and headed for the till. The guy behind the counter said "11." I said "Records or dollars?" He said "Dollars." It wasn't until I was back at the hotel that I realized it was 11 records and should have cost about eight bucks, but I didn't care. I had found several old favorites I thought I'd never own.

The floodgates opened several years later when an enterprising local woman launched a service called The Record Hunter out of her apartment in 1973. A little blurb in the newspaper alerted me to her and over the next year or so I bought dozens of old discs from her, including -- finally -- replacements for those wrecked records.

At the same time, conventional record stores were opening oldies sections, and virtually all of the major labels started mining their back catalog, both with reissued 45s and LP compilations.

Ultimately, I managed to put together a pretty good representation of ‘50s and ‘60s music (I arbitrarily cut it off at 1970, for some reason, although I certainly kept buying records after that).

The challenge all of that represented seems very improbable now. My musings on it were prompted by a recent visit to the local discount store, where earlier I had noticed a rack of cheap CDs ($6 to $10) with a bunch of old tracks. At that price, I could justify buying a disc for one or two cuts. But even if I was starting from scratch, I could put together a fairly decent selection from those discs alone, without ever visiting a music store.

And yes, I have mostly duplicated my old vinyl oldies collection in digital form. And no, I'm not going to lend them to my sister.

...Ian G. Masters
ian@mastersonaudio.com


MASTERS ON AUDIO AND VIDEOAll Contents Copyright © 2004
Schneider Publishing Inc., All Rights Reserved.
Any reproduction of content on
this site without permission is strictly forbidden.