MASTERS ON AUDIO AND VIDEOVideo Archives

September 1, 2001

 

Get the Clutter Off My TV Screen!

"Say, Ian, doesn't the TV picture look a little washed out? Maybe you could take the brightness down just a bit."

"No problem dear. I'll just get out the ol' remote control and lemme see. . .

Press MENU.

[A list of four or five control options appears, each emblazoned with a neat, if meaningless symbol and a fairly cryptic verbal designation. About half the picture is obscured.]

Press the +/- rocker switch until the little colored pointer is positioned opposite the most likely candidate.

Press ENTER.

[Another list of options appears, including several factory-preset color balances and general audio and video categories.]

Press +/- until the pointer is opposite "Video."

Press ENTER.

[Half a dozen control bars fill the screen, indicating the current settings for color, tint, brightness, sharpness, and so forth.]

Press +/- until the brightness bar is highlighted.

Press ENTER.

[The brightness bar drops to the bottom of the screen. The other functions disappear.]

Press +/- to adjust the brightness to the desired setting.

Press ENTER.

[The screen re-fills with the control bars.]

Press MENU.

I'm not making this up! This complex sequence of instructions accomplishes what I can do on my twenty-year-old bedroom TV in one second by tweaking a knob, and it doesn't fill the screen with gibberish. But at some point, engineers with floppies for brains were turned loose in the video labs, and the nerdification of the common TV has been the unwelcome result.

That's not to deny that today's sets do a great deal more than those of only a few years ago, and generally do it better. If memory serves, my older set had an instruction manual that ran to about four pages, mostly taken up with explaining how to attach an antenna (the only signal source) and how to keep the wood-grain cabinet in shape. Now the range of things you can do with a TV monitor is vast, from automatic programming to digital picture manipulation.

The initial setup of a new television set can take most of a day, as preferred channels are entered, the clock and calendars set, a variety of picture balance modes entered, and so forth. For these once-in-a-while duties, the computer-like on-screen menu is a very useful device. But after I have programmed all this info once, I want it out of my face!

The wireless remote control of one TV set I played with recently had 51 buttons and two switches. These controlled what were probably several dozen functions, but every time I tried to do anything, however simple, the screen filled with type, obliterating the picture I was trying to watch.

Frankly, I don't need multi-colored bar graphs on screen to tell me I am turning up the volume or reducing the contrast. I also don't need a full readout of a station's channel number, call letters, and audio status every time I change the channel. At least I would like to have the option of seeing this stuff or not, but few sets give me that.

As a consequence, I frequently leave a picture less than perfectly tuned because cluttering it up with letters and symbols would distract the other viewers in the room (as they are quick to point out when I do make adjustments).

It seems to me that manufacturers of these high-end television sets could make their products easier to use and less irksome by simplifying the everyday functions and giving users the option of displaying what's going on or not. The elaborate command sequences that are now common are probably appropriate for a TV's initial setup: you hardly want to risk altering some basic function by an inadvertent jab at the remote when you are merely trying to hit the mute to answer the phone.

But given the number of controls on the average remote, it would seem to make sense to provide simple up/down pairs of buttons not only for volume but for brightness, contrast, sharpness, color, tint, and possibly some audio functions such as bass and treble. Other things you are likely to want to tinker with fairly frequently could have simple on/off buttons.

A lot of technology has gone into today's top television monitors, and I suppose it's natural that the designers want to display that. But I know the technology's there and I don't have to see it every time I pick up the remote.

...Ian G. Masters
ian@mastersonaudio.com 


MASTERS ON AUDIO AND VIDEOAll Contents Copyright © 2001
Schneider Publishing Inc., All Rights Reserved.
Any reproduction of content on
this site without permission is strictly forbidden.