MASTERS ON AUDIO AND VIDEOVideo Archives

August 15, 2003

 

TV: A 20th-Century Epiphany

Some technologies take the world by surprise. Nobody knew they needed a microwave oven, for instance, until they were on dealers' shelves. But television was never like that: From the moment people started sending messages over long distances by wire, and later by radio, it was generally assumed that someone would eventually figure out how to send moving pictures that way. The word "television" was coined long before it was a reality.

The problem the early developers had to face was how to turn a parallel process into a sequential one. When we view an object, millions of sensors in the back of our eyes react to it, and send their information to our brains simultaneously. It would be theoretically possible to devise a television system that uses numerous light sensors, each connected by its own circuit to a corresponding light emitter in the receiver, but that would hardly be practical.

Instead, the transmitter has to be break up the image into smaller areas, and "read" the amount of light each area reflects in a fixed pattern. The transmitter then sends the sequence of changing voltage over a single circuit, and the receiver reassembles it. For this to work, the transmitter must read a large enough number of points of light for the image to be clear, and the process has to repeat often enough for the movement to appear smooth, without the image flickering.

The process is called "scanning," and German engineer Paul Nipkow proposed a method of accomplishing it as early as 1884. He suggested a spinning disc with a spiral of small holes in it. As each hole passed the object, the hole would trace a horizontal line across the object, exposing changes of light along that line to a photosensitive device on the other side of the disc. The receiver would have a similar disc, which would "paint" the image for the viewer.

A Scottish electrical engineer named John Logie Baird actually made this work. In 1924, he was able to transmit the outlines of objects, then recognizable faces. Within two years, he succeeded in producing moving images -- the first true television pictures. Baird's original disc had 30 holes, which yielded a vertical resolution of only 30 lines. Eventually he increased this to 240 lines, but in the end, an all-electronic system was chosen for Britain.

The real father of television, at least in the UK, was Sir Isaac Schoenberg, a radio expert from the Soviet Union. From 1931 on, he headed a research effort to create a television system based on the Emitron camera tube and a cathode-ray display. The first broadcasts using Schoenberg's standard went on the air in 1936; it became the exclusive standard the next year when the BBC dropped Baird's mechanical system, and remained so until the 1960s.

Crucial to that development was the cathode-ray picture tube, the first practical commercial version of which Allen B. Du Mont had perfected in the United States. Du Mont went on to be the first manufacturer of television sets in the US in 1937, two years before TV broadcasting began.

The real push for television in North America came when Vladimir K. Zworykin teamed up with RCA. Zworykin was born and educated in Russia but immigrated to the United States after the First World War. He worked initially for Westinghouse, where he developed the iconoscope -- the pickup tube used in all early TV cameras -- and the kinescope, which is the basis of conventional television picture tubes to this day. In 1929, some officials at RCA saw a demonstration of Zworykin's system and hired him.

RCA's subsidiary, NBC, produced the first American television broadcast at the New York World's Fair in 1939, and by the next year, almost two dozen stations were on the air, serving some 10,000 viewers. But everything ground to a halt, in both Britain and the US, when the Second World War came. The factories that otherwise might make TV sets were occupied making military electronics, such as radar sets.

Things picked up quickly after the war, however, and by 1946 both the BBC in the UK and the American stations were back on the air. In the US, there were some 10 million sets in use by 1951, and 50 million by the end of the decade. Similar growth occurred in Britain. Canadian television broadcasting began in September 1952 in Montreal and Toronto.

All of this activity was monochromatic, of course, but just as television itself had been inevitable, so was color TV. In fact, both Baird and Zworykin had developed color systems as far back as 1928.

Neither of those came to anything, but in 1940 Peter Goldmark demonstrated a color technology that would briefly have official status after the war. Goldmark was a Hungarian-born American engineer who would later gain renown as the man behind the vinyl LP. His initial development was the first commercial color television system, which used a spinning disc that contained three color filters. Each successive frame would be filtered through one of these, and a corresponding filter would be in the receiving set.

In the end, just as mechanical means had been rejected for television itself, mechanical color was mostly a curiosity as well. Even as Goldmark's disc was being demonstrated, an all-electronic alternative did exist. France's George Valensi patented a system in 1938 that would form the basis for compatible color -- signals that, without modification, would reproduce properly on both color and black-and-white sets.

By 1950, serious efforts were being made to find a color system for North America, and the National Television System Committee (NTSC) -- an industry body -- set itself the task of choosing a standard. By 1953, they had approved a scheme developed by RCA, which was accepted by the American broadcast regulators that year. It was called NTSC after the committee and has remained unchanged to this day.

Although the standard was established in the early 1950s, a majority of US programming was not in color until the late 1960s. Other countries were even slower off the mark. In Europe, for instance, two color systems emerged -- incompatible with each other and with NTSC -- but they weren't universally accepted until the 1970s.

Telefunken developed the more common system in Germany, and called it "phase alternating line" or PAL. It was based on the NTSC system but with improved color stability. France adopted a system named SECAM (système électronique couleur avec mémoire), which further enhanced color performance. Both were based on the European standard of 625 scanning lines and 25 frames per second, rather than NTSC's 525 lines and 30 frames. North America and Japan use the NTSC system, while France and most of the former Communist states of Eastern Europe use SECAM, and practically everybody else uses PAL.

One remarkable aspect of television technology is that, except for the addition of color, it hasn't changed in more than half a century. A set bought in 1946 would work with today's signals. What has changed dramatically is the way TV pictures are delivered. Cable TV has been around from the beginning, originally to provide service to communities where distance or topography made reception difficult. It took off in Canada in the 1960s as a means of delivering relatively noise-free color pictures from US stations. Its progress south of the border was slower. It became a mass item when specialty channels delivered only on cable -- movies and sports, mainly -- were introduced. Cable now serves the majority of households in both countries.

The main competitor to cable is the direct-to-home (DTH) digital satellite, which arrived in the US in 1994, and in Canada two years later. Able to deliver more channels and better quality than conventional analog cable, DTH has prompted the main cable systems to introduce digital versions of their premium signals.

The end is coming for this 60-plus-year-old technology, of course, as digital television picks up steam around the world -- its first true upgrade ever -- but the familiar TV systems have had a remarkable run.

...Ian G. Masters
ian@mastersonaudio.com


MASTERS ON AUDIO AND VIDEOAll Contents Copyright © 2003
Schneider Publishing Inc., All Rights Reserved.
Any reproduction of content on
this site without permission is strictly forbidden.